Skip to Content

Reader Round-Up: Top 5 Sunless Tanners

I recently ran out of my third bottle of my favorite sunless tanner and before scooping up another bottle I polled y’all to see if there’s one I should try. There were some requests to share the results so here they are — the top 5! I’m going to try the Tan Luxe next!

  1. Tan Luxe – The Gradual (Ulta / Sephora)
  2. St. Tropez (Ulta / Sephora / Amazon)
  3. Loving Tan (Ulta / Amazon)
  4. Jergens Natural Glow (Amazon / Walmart / Target)
  5. Josie Maran Liquid Gold Oil (Sephora / Amazon)

You'll also love


Thursday 16th of January 2020

I like the Target version (up&up) jergen's better than the name brand. It has a much better smell.


Tuesday 14th of January 2020

i just bought the isle of paradise & love it!

Lindsey R

Monday 13th of January 2020

Do you follow Things I Bought And Liked on Instagram? I think her top choice is Tan Luxe, too.


Monday 13th of January 2020

I swear by that Jergens Gradual Tan, and I'm actually about to order the Isle of Paradise drops .... we'll see!

Laura Toler

Monday 13th of January 2020

You may also want to try Tan Physics. It is the best I have ever used. Get many compliments on my tan. Many of my friends have started using it. Color is so natural. Since I exercise 6 days a week, I apply it so I don't look so pale. No problems applying to my face

Rachel A Paredes

Tuesday 14th of January 2020

Great to know thx