Non-Candy Easter Basket Fillers for Boys & Girls

Looking for creative Easter Basket Fillers that go beyond the usual candy options? I’ve got you covered!

Whether you’re looking to surprise your kids with some fresh, fun items for Easter or just want to mix things up, these non-candy basket fillers are sure to be hits. I love finding unique, practical, and playful gifts that the kids can actually use and enjoy long after Easter weekend is over. From sports gear to creative toys and even accessories they can wear, these basket stuffers are the perfect way to celebrate the season without the sugar overload.

But before we go any further, I want to suggest you also check out my post sharing my Easter Basket Fillers for the TWEENS:

Easter Basket Stuffers for Tween Girls
Easter Basket Stuffers for Tween Boys
Easter Basket Stuffers for Boys & Girls
I am also keeping THIS LIST up to date right now with new items as I find them!

Alright, let’s get down to it!

Easter Basket Fillers For The Girls

I am really excited to fill Caroline’s basket this year with these goodies. If I had to pick my top 5 it would be hard but I guess I’d go with a mix of things she already owns and loves, as well as a few new things I cannot wait for the bunny to bring her!

As a reminder, if you see something that you like, it likely comes in lots of colors, patterns, or styles, so make sure to double check!

Slushy Maker Squeeze Cup: I do not understand how this magic works, but it WORKS. You can turn any liquid into a slushy with this cup! Caroline has made all sorts of slushies — with yoohoos, sodas, juices, etc.!
Scratch Art Mini Notes: Caroline is absolutely obsessed with these. She uses them ALL the time!
Pool Treasure Diving Gems: How fun are these dive gems for the pool?! A really cute alternative to the traditional dive sticks!
Clay Bead Bracelet Set: We have purchased this set SO many times and it provides endless hours of bracelet making fun for Caroline and her friends.
Genius Square Game: One of my girlfriends raved about this STEM puzzle game. She said it’s super easy to learn and you can play it pretty quickly — and it’s a good problem-solving brain game! Caroline loves games as much as me so I cannot wait to learn this with her.

Easter Basket Fillers for Girls

Find all these fillers and way more HERE!

Easter Basket Fillers For The Boys

Thomas is really sports-obsessed right now so his basket is filled with tons of sports-themed gifts and games! My top 5 picks from this round-up include…

Water Football: We purchase this exact football almost every year (because we somehow end up losing it by the end of summer). Perfect for the beach, pool, lake, park, and more.
I Survived Box Set: Thomas blew through these books SO fast. These books are absolutely thrilling with action packed stories.
NFL Flag Football Set: Thomas received this for Christmas and has absolutely LOVED playing with the neighborhood boys!
Extreme Geyser Tube: I’ve shared this a few times but it really is SO cool and is the perfect Easter basket stuffer. This soda lab experiment is SO fun, can be used again and again, and best of all — it’s an outdoor activity for the kids to do with friends, neighbors, etc. I continue to purchase mentos and 2 liters — this has been such a big hit on our street!
High-Bounce Balls: These will blow your mind with how high they can go!