Fall soups officially make their comeback the second we spot an orange leaf or the morning temp dips below 65…and Soup Sunday comes with it! It’s the coziest little tradition: a big pot of soup simmering on the stove, an oversized sweatshirt, and football playing in the background.
I’ve rounded up some of our forever favorite fall soups, the ones we keep in rotation all season long. I love to double (or triple) them for the freezer, perfect for those nights when we need a hug in a bowl. This roundup includes soups I’ve served for my Supper Club, entered into Soup Cook-Off contests, and brought to life on countless chilly Sundays.
1. Sausage & Cheese Tortellini Soup
Kicking off the list with Matt’s all-time favorite. I first shared this gem back in 2016—and it’s stayed at the top of our rotation ever since. Packed with cheesy tortellini, hearty sausage, and a sneaky bag of spinach hidden in the broth, it’s the kind of Soup Sunday staple that even picky eaters end up asking for.
Beyond being a family go-to, this soup has made its rounds at Community Group gatherings and Supper Club dinners, and it’s even earned bragging rights in my Soup Cook-Off. Trust me, you can’t go wrong starting your soup season with this one.
2. Chicken Enchilada Soup
My personal favorite, and the one Matt rates 15 out of 10 every time! It’s a cheesy, bold, and slightly spicy soup that tastes like your favorite enchiladas—just in cozy, spoonable form. It’s loaded with shredded chicken, black beans, and corn, all simmered in a creamy enchilada-style broth.
3. Lasagna Soup
This is the recipe that made me prefer lasagna in soup form. We sometimes kick off Soup Sunday with it, and it’s a fall staple with 8+ years under its belt. Hearty beef, pasta noodles, tomato-rich broth, and a dreamy ricotta-cheese blend—what’s not to love? It’s kid-approved, easy, and a crock-pot crowd-pleaser for anyone who loves a little cheesy nostalgia in a bowl.
4. Creamy Zuppa Toscana Soup (Olive Garden Copycat)
This one earned a spot at Supper Club—which tells you everything you need to know. It’s creamy, garlicky, and loaded with sausage, potatoes, and kale. Basically, Olive Garden who? Bonus: I’ve also made a dairy-free version with coconut milk that turned out even better than I expected.
5. Chicken Tortilla Slow Cooker Soup
This one’s as easy as it gets. Just dump everything in the slow cooker and go live your life while it does its thing. It’s flavorful, comforting, and perfect for piling high with toppings. I’ve made it for neighbors, friends, and plenty of Soup Sundays, and it never disappoints.
6. Buffalo Ground Chicken Chili
If you’re craving comfort with a spicy edge, this chili is it. This one comes together in under 30 minutes with ground chicken, buffalo sauce, and ranch seasoning. Perfect for a cozy dinner, game day, and it beautifully transforms into next-day nachos.
7. Taco Soup
Probably the soup we make the most all season. This classic is just SO good and SO easy. Who doesn’t love tacos…in soup form?! And there’s a secret ingredient in this soup that makes it trump any other taco soup recipe out there…
8. Creamy Bacon and Tomato Soup
Smoky bacon, rich tomatoes, and fresh basil come together in this elevated take on classic tomato soup. It’s simple, satisfying, and especially perfect with a grilled cheese on the side. The kind of weeknight dinner that feels special without trying too hard.
9. White Bean Chicken Chili
Hearty and filling, this chili can simmer on the stove or let it do its thing in the slow cooker. It’s loaded with shredded chicken, white beans, green chilis, and a little lime for brightness.
10. Italian Sausage Orzo Soup
This one is soooooooooo easy it will blow your mind. It’s hearty, flavorful and the whole family gives it two thumbs up. Proo tip: This soup makes for the perfect meal to deliver to someone in need, as they can enjoy it right away or freeze it for later, it always hits the spot.
11. Stuffed Pepper Soup
This healthy soup is stuffed with goodness — bell peppers, cauliflower rice, ground beef, and all the cozy, savory vibes you want without feeling heavy. It’s hearty and definitely hits the spot.
12. The Best Damn Chili
This thick, deeply flavorful chili ticks all the boxes for serving on game day, hosting a crowd, or warming up on a cold evening. Packed with bold, deep flavors and slow-cooked to perfection in your crockpot or on the stovetop, this one-pot wonder is as easy to make as it is delicious.
13. Potato & Cauliflower Soup
This one blends the cozy flavor of baked potato soup with a sneaky cauliflower twist. It’s creamy, cheesy, and surprisingly filling—and no one ever guesses there’s extra veggies packed in. Top with shredded cheddar, green onions, and maybe a little sour cream if you’re feeling fancy.
14. Tomato Lentil Soup
Hearty, flavorful, and packed with plant-based protein, this tomato lentil soup is both simple and satisfying. The tender red lentils cook down into a creamy texture while the tomatoes add richness and depth. It’s cozy, wholesome, and perfect for a meatless night.
15. Spiced Chickpea Stew with Coconut and Turmeric
This isn’t my recipe—it’s a viral, reader-must-try that one of my girlfriends made for Supper Club once, and now I make every season. Coconut and turmeric give those chickpeas serious warmth, while the greens add color and texture. It’s a cozy, subtly exotic twist on Soup Sunday that even the non-vegan crowd approves of.
Find all of our FAVORITE SOUP RECIPES HERE.
Now it’s your turn…share your favorite soup recipe with me (and everyone else) in the comments below!
*post originally published October 2021 and updated with new recipes and photographs September 2025.
